Desks and Bells
Policy

Supreme Court Hears Colorado Preschool Funding Dispute

The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments on whether Colorado can exclude Catholic preschools from its universal preschool program over their refusal to enroll children of same-sex parents.

The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments on whether Colorado can exclude Catholic preschools from its universal...

The U.S. Supreme Court hears oral arguments Tuesday in a case that will decide if religious preschools can receive public funding while rejecting children of gay parents. The dispute centers on Colorado's universal preschool program, which offers families 15 hours of free preschool weekly at a value of over $6,000 per child.

Two Catholic parishes, St. Mary Catholic Parish in Littleton and St. Bernadette Catholic Parish in Lakewood, are suing the state. They argue that a program requirement to provide an equal opportunity to enroll, regardless of a parent's sexual orientation or gender identity, violates their religious freedom. The schools, which are among 34 preschools overseen by the Archdiocese of Denver, will not admit families that do not support Catholic teachings on marriage and sex. As a result, none of the archdiocese's preschools participate in the state program.

The Core Legal Conflict

The plaintiffs claim Colorado is excluding them from a public benefit because of their religious exercise, which they say violates the First Amendment's free exercise clause. They are represented by The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty. "They can't get the same benefit that everyone in the state is getting," said their lawyer, Amanda Dixon. The state counters that it is applying a neutral, generally applicable rule to all providers. Colorado argues that no publicly funded preschool can turn away children based on protected characteristics like a parent's identity.

The Program's Rules and Reach

Colorado's universal preschool program, approved by voters in 2020, uses a mixed-delivery system. Public, private, and faith-based providers can participate if they meet state quality standards and sign a contract agreeing to a nondiscrimination provision. The state estimates roughly 40,000 eligible children are served by nearly 2,000 providers. The provision mandates that all participating schools give eligible children an equal opportunity to enroll, irrespective of race, religious affiliation, sexual orientation, gender identity, income, or disability.

When the program launched, the Archdiocese of Denver sought a religious exemption from this mandate. The state denied the request, informing the archdiocese that while it could give enrollment preference to its members, it could not discriminate in violation of state statute. Program regulations were later amended, removing the option for faith-based providers to limit enrollment solely to congregants.

A Line of Precedent

This case continues a recent trend of Supreme Court rulings on public funding for religious institutions. The plaintiffs argue their situation falls under the 2022 ruling in Carson v. Makin, which held that states cannot exclude religious schools from publicly funded tuition assistance programs based on their religious character. Lower courts, however, ruled against the Catholic preschools. They found that Carson applies only when exclusions are explicitly based on religion, not when a neutral rule incidentally burdens religious practice.

The state urges the justices not to extend Carson. It warns that doing so would require scrutinizing every public benefit condition that incidentally affects religious conduct. The decision may also clarify the relationship between Carson and the 1990 precedent Employment Division v. Smith, which held that neutral laws of general application do not violate the Free Exercise Clause.

Broader Implications

The outcome will affect more than just these two schools. It will determine whether states can enforce anti-discrimination protections in publicly funded educational programs when they conflict with religious beliefs. Suzanne Goldberg, a law professor at Columbia Law School, said the case raises an important question about whether states can require non-discrimination when providing specialized funding.

This is one of three major education cases the Supreme Court will hear this term. Later, it will consider a Title IX employment dispute and a case concerning K-12 admissions policies designed to diversify student bodies. A decision in the Colorado preschool case is expected before the court's summer recess. The ruling will define the limits of religious liberty in state-funded education programs for young children.

Topics

#Policy

Related coverage

More from Policy