Ohio Court Rules EdChoice Voucher Program Unconstitutional
An Ohio appeals court ruled the state's EdChoice voucher program violates the constitution by undermining public school funding, a decision that could reshape education policy as federal school choice initiatives loom.

The Ohio 10th District Court of Appeals ruled on October 15, 2026, that the EdChoice voucher program violates the state constitution by undermining public school financial integrity and cherry-picking students. The court found the program violates Ohio's requirement for a "thorough and efficient" public school system. It upheld a lower court's ruling that the scholarship program is unconstitutional.
The lawsuit, Columbus City School District, et al. V. State of Ohio, was filed by a coalition of school districts in 2022. The court stated that without EdChoice funding in fiscal years 2023 and 2024, the state's public school funding plan could have been fully funded. The program is also eroding support for local school levies by reducing public school enrollment and finances.
Funding Impact on Public Schools
The ruling highlights severe funding shortfalls for public schools linked to the voucher program. In fiscal years 2023 and 2024, public schools received only 50% and 66% of the Fair School Funding Plan, respectively.
| Fiscal Year | Percentage of Plan Funded |
|---|---|
| 2023 | 50% |
| 2024 | 66% |
In fiscal year 2024, this translated to public schools receiving $7.1 billion instead of the fully funded $7.8 billion.
Program Cost and Legal Status
The school choice program cost taxpayers almost $1.4 billion in fiscal years 2024 and 2025. The EdChoice program provides scholarships of up to $8,400 for eligible students to attend nonpublic schools of their families’ choice. Agudath Israel of Ohio stated that every child in Ohio is eligible for a scholarship under the program.
The court’s decision does not immediately end the program. Families can continue using their scholarships while the legal process moves forward. The case is expected to be appealed to the Ohio Supreme Court. The ruling is limited to the current structure and funding of Ohio's EdChoice program and does not apply to all school voucher programs.
Broader Context and Stakeholder Views
The decision arrives as Ohio has opted into a new nationwide federal school choice program that begins in 2027. That initiative is expected to provide $26 billion annually in taxpayer contributions. Supporters argue that school vouchers give parents greater freedom to choose an education that fits their children’s needs, including religious education. Critics contend that public funding for private schools undermines the state’s public education system.
Naaz Modan said, "The EdChoice Scholarship Program poses an existential threat to Ohio’s public school system."
Rabbi Yitz Frank, executive director of Agudath Israel of Ohio, expressed disappointment but confidence. While we are disappointed by today’s ruling, we remain confident that EdChoice will ultimately be upheld, he said. He noted his organization has played an active role in advocating for and expanding the program. Families can continue using scholarships while the legal process moves forward.





