Desks and Bells
Policy

Justice Department Sues Anne Arundel Schools Over Gender Policy

The U.S. Department of Justice sued Anne Arundel County Public Schools on Tuesday, alleging its gender identity policies violate federal student privacy laws by withholding information from parents.

The U.S. Department of Justice sued Anne Arundel County Public Schools on Tuesday, alleging its gender identity policies...

The U.S. Department of Justice filed a lawsuit against Anne Arundel County Public Schools on Tuesday. The action, lodged in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, alleges the district violated the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act and the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment. Federal officials accuse the district of withholding gender identity information from parents and secretly facilitating student social transitions.

The complaint states the district's policies direct staff to solicit, document, and act on a student's self-identified name, pronouns, and gender identity without notifying parents. This information is then reported to the Maryland State Department of Education. The district designates such details as confidential, instructing staff to withhold them from parents based on safety concerns. The lawsuit seeks to block these policies and force the district into compliance with federal law.

One specific allegation involves a student referred to as Mary Doe. Staff allegedly called her by a male name that did not match her legal name and disclosed this to other parents while withholding it from her own. The Justice Department asserts the district failed to provide parents their right to inspect and review education records. Two families had previously sued the district, alleging staff helped a student transition while keeping parents in the dark.

District disputes allegations and defends policy changes

An Anne Arundel County schools spokesperson stated the district disagrees with the allegations and stands by its compliance with FERPA and PPRA. The district amended its policies on August 19. The updated policy clarifies that parents retain the right to inspect and review their children's complete education records, including gender identity and preferred name information.

In a letter to families, Superintendent Mark Bedell stated no policy or practice could interfere with parents’ rights under FERPA. He said no policy can interfere with parents' rights to information about a student's gender identity, transgender status, sexual orientation, preferred name, or pronouns. The Justice Department called the policy change insufficient because it did not allow parents to challenge or change content they believe violates their child's privacy rights. The district stated it will address the claims in court filings and has no further comment.

Context of federal pressure and prior investigations

This lawsuit follows a pattern of federal action. The Trump administration warned state attorneys general in early October that schools must comply with federal privacy laws requiring written parental consent for any activity evaluating mental health. The administration previously pressed a Kansas school district over a similar student privacy policy in July.

The Education Department has also announced investigations into three California school districts over invasive questionnaires in ethnic studies courses that included gender identity and sexual orientation topics. Anne Arundel's policy change in August occurred after pressure from the Trump administration, which had threatened legal action and loss of federal funding.

Political and administrative backdrop

The legal challenge unfolds against a political backdrop where the Trump administration has targeted transgender policies. The President has issued executive actions recognizing only two sexes and has cast transgender identity as a lie. The administration has also targeted educational institutions over climate initiatives, pro-Palestinian protests, and diversity programs.

The U.S. Education Department previously accused Anne Arundel County of violating federal law by classifying student gender identity information as confidential medical information that cannot be shared with parents. Superintendent Dr. Mark Bedell stated the district was updating policies to create safe and inclusive environments for LGBTQ+ students while ensuring FERPA compliance. Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon stated on Tuesday that schools should not discuss preferred pronouns or gender identity with a student without parental notification and consent. The case will now proceed through federal court filings.

Topics

#Policy

Related coverage

More from Policy