School budget crisis deepens as enrollment falls and costs rise
Nationwide public school enrollment has dropped by over 1.4 million students since the pandemic, straining district finances as special education costs climb and temporary federal aid expires, leading to contentious debates over school closures and budget cuts.

Public school enrollment has declined by more than 1.4 million students since the pandemic, creating a widespread school budget crisis. One out of every four public schools in the U.S. has lost 15 percent or more of its student population since 2019, primarily due to declining birth rates and the expansion of school choice options. This decline directly threatens funding and program sustainability, as state aid is typically tied to student counts.
In Seattle, enrollment fell by roughly 8 percent since 2019, to below 49,000 students. The Central Falls School District in Rhode Island now has 2,241 students, down from 2,404 at the start of the school year and the lowest in over a decade. Central Falls High School enrollment is now in the 600s, down from 800. Superintendent Stephanie Downey Toledo stated enrollment was around 3,000 when she started eight years ago.
About 60 high school students are no longer enrolled since the start of the year, with 30 having graduated in August. The loss of hundreds of students could result in millions of dollars less in funding. The superintendent said new registrations have declined significantly, with families citing housing changes or choosing charter or career programs.
Financial realities of school operations
More than $190 billion in federal pandemic relief aid was allocated to school districts, allowing staffing levels to be maintained. Teacher headcounts have grown by 1 percent nationwide despite the enrollment decline. Disability diagnoses are rising, adding to financial strain as special education costs increase.
Employee pay and benefits account for roughly 80 percent of a district’s budget, making payroll the primary financial challenge. School finance expert Jason Willis warned against using rainy day funds for ongoing expenses like salaries, stating it does not resolve structural financial issues. Closing a school yields only modest and temporary budget relief, according to research from Arkansas, California, and Chicago.
Liza Rankin summarized the dilemma: "Closing schools doesn’t save much money to begin with. Payroll is where the big money is."
Community resistance to school closures
Local pushback has halted closure proposals in major cities. In 2024, Seattle’s superintendent proposed closing up to a fifth of its schools due to low enrollment but scrapped the plan after community resistance. Nearly four decades ago, state auditors warned Seattle Public Schools about a budget crisis requiring campus closures.
San Francisco’s enrollment fell 10 percent since 2019, leading to a $100 million-plus deficit and a shelved proposal to close more than a dozen schools in late 2024. The district's current budget projects a $26 million deficit in the following school year, relying on early retirements and central office cuts to avoid closures. San Francisco’s rainy day fund was nearly $139 million last year, with expectations to draw it down to $52 million over the next two years. A new superintendent there signed an $183 million contract with the United Educators of San Francisco earlier this year.
Voices from a district meeting
At a recent meeting opened at an elementary school, Principal Buddy Comet noted declining enrollment but complex student needs. A parent suggested a school running from kindergarten through sixth grade, a longer school day, and more parking. Another parent asked for more after-school programs. An eighth grader said they have had only gym for two years and no access to advanced math, and requested an assistant principal.
The district's director of operations and safety, Rory Marty, introduced themselves to the new board. A teacher speaking online noted it had been a year since the board was first seated, ending 34 years of state control. The board tabled its superintendent evaluation policy for a second straight month.
At least 21 state takeovers of school districts have occurred since 2023, limiting local flexibility in budget decisions and staffing. In Central Falls, the superintendent said class sizes are currently very low, with a grade potentially having three first-grade classes next year instead of four. The district is considering eliminating instructional coaches and new after-school programs due to budget constraints. The district will begin demolition of the old high school while planning for fiscal 2028 budget constraints.





