Desks and Bells
Districts

NYC Public School Enrollment Drops 3%, Budgets Under Strain

New York City public schools lost 23,000 students this year, the largest single-year decline since the pandemic, raising urgent questions about budget sustainability and potential school closures.

New York City public schools lost 23,000 students this year, the largest single-year decline since the pandemic, raising...

New York City public school enrollment has dropped by nearly 3% this year. The system lost about 23,000 students.

Preliminary numbers from the Education Department show K-12 schools lost 23,018 students. Total enrollment, when including city-funded preschool programs, fell by 2.6% to 863,100 students. This follows a 2.4% drop last year. The data is preliminary and could change if more students enroll before the year ends. The city’s public schools had about 766,900 students as of October 31.

This decline continues a decade-long trend where the city has lost nearly 20% of its students, or about 200,000 children. The trend accelerated during COVID-19 as families left the five boroughs and was further impacted by federal immigration policies. Enrollment is projected to plummet by another 130,000 students by the 2034-35 school year.

Fiscal pressures mount

The sustained enrollment drop puts immense strain on the city's budget. Schools are funded on a per-student basis, so losing students normally reduces funding. To protect schools, the city has spent nearly $2 billion since 2020 to keep budgets steady despite declining enrollment. The cost of this 'hold harmless' policy reached nearly $290 million this year alone.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani kept school budgets whole in his first budget deal. However, experts note this approach is inequitable as it allows schools with declining enrollment to spend more per student. The decline has, conversely, aided the city in meeting a state law requirement to reduce class sizes.

Policy uncertainty ahead

Officials have declined to confirm whether the 'hold harmless' policy will continue. The decline has prompted more local officials and budget watchdogs to raise concerns about its long-term sustainability.

With budgets under pressure, the city is moving toward school closures and mergers. It is considering closing two small schools in Harlem, one in Brooklyn, and merging two sets of schools in the Bronx and Brooklyn. The Panel for Educational Policy is expected to vote on these closure and merger proposals within the next two months.

Kamar Samuels said, "We’ve started to have conversations in communities."

A broader trend

The city's situation reflects a national pattern. Thirty states have seen public school enrollment declines since 2014, with large systems in Los Angeles, Chicago, Philadelphia, and Houston also affected.

Within the overall decline, there was a slight enrollment increase in city-funded preschool programs. This was due to a new program for 2,000 2-year-olds and increased 4-year-old prekindergarten sign-ups under the Mamdani administration's new childcare programs.

The Panel for Educational Policy will vote on closure and merger proposals within the next two months.

Related coverage

More from Districts