Desks and Bells
Students

NYC's small schools crisis deepens as enrollment falls

The number of New York City public schools with fewer than 250 students has soared from 42 to 335 over 25 years, forcing officials to consider community-driven mergers or closures amid a steep, ongoing enrollment decline.

The number of New York City public schools with fewer than 250 students has soared from 42 to 335 over 25 years, forcing...

The number of New York City schools with fewer than 250 students has multiplied eightfold over the past 25 years, from 42 to 335. Enrollment in public schools is down 187,000 over the past 12 years to 790,000, driving the small schools crisis.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani has not shared a vision for addressing the pressing challenges in the school system. The K-12 student population is projected to fall almost as much in the decade to come. Chancellor Kamar Samuels has indicated he does not want to create a systemwide plan to reduce the number of schools and prefers community-driven consolidation.

Community-driven consolidation efforts underway

Chancellor Samuels has launched working groups in five districts to develop community-driven consolidation plans and promised to expand them citywide. None of the five working groups includes high schools. Officials have not shared a timeline for this process.

Samuels is described as highly skilled at cultivating consensus and willing to press forward without it if needed to serve students better. He previously helped draw up plans to close three small middle schools on the Upper West Side, which were withdrawn due to community opposition.

School closures proposed amid limited options

Superintendents have proposed closing at least two underenrolled schools, including a high school in Harlem and a middle school in the South Bronx. Adriana Alicea, chair of the Panel for Educational Policy's committee on school utilization, said the panel wants evidence that officials have engaged with school communities and considered alternatives to closure.

The city has spent almost $2 billion since 2010 on the 'hold harmless' policy to keep school budgets steady despite enrollment loss. Over the same period, the number of principals grew 11% to 1,610 and the number of assistant principals jumped 31% to 3,518.

Small schools face unique challenges

Murry Bergtraum High School for Business Careers is the city's smallest traditional high school with roughly 90 students. Its per-student budget is nearly twice the city average, yet it offers only two math courses: Algebra I and II, with one math teacher. Students have been required to attend night school to graduate due to these limited academic offerings.

Amy Piller, principal of Urban Assembly Maker Academy which shares a building with Murry Bergtraum, leads a school that is a finalist for a grant to transform an unused locker room into a shared academic space for all schools on the campus.

Alternative models explored

Some campuses have already pioneered sharing solutions. Principals at the Theodore Roosevelt campus in The Bronx opened advanced courses like calculus and statistics to the entire campus a decade ago. At the Lehman High School campus, also in The Bronx, principals aligned their bell schedules in 2016 to offer courses to all students on the campus.

The city has 72 high schools with fewer than 250 students located on shared campuses. The Education Department is now considering creating 'campus working groups' for high schools as a potential solution. Karin Goldmark noted, "The challenge now is that there is such a backlog of tough decisions."

Related coverage

More from Students